Teresa Harmon, one of the three panelists who presented “2025 Commercial Law Developments,” a program at the ABA Business Law Section’s 2026 Fall Meeting in Chicago, made sure nobody left town without knowing the seven toppings a real Chicago hot dog requires. Skip one—the mustard (not ketchup), the neon-green relish, the celery salt—and it isn’t a Chicago dog. As the panel’s cases showed, a security agreement works the same way: Miss one required element, and the security interest can be at risk.
That was the spirit of “2025 Commercial Law Developments.” The panel reviewed the year’s most notable decisions in secured transactions and commercial finance. As panelist Steven Weise noted, revised Article 9 has been in effect for about twenty-five years, yet many of the year’s cases turned on basic mistakes.
Presented by the Uniform Commercial Code Committee and co-sponsored by the Commercial Finance Committee, the program featured three panelists who took turns presenting cases: Harmon, partner and co-managing partner of the Chicago office at Sidley Austin LLP; Weise, partner at Proskauer Rose LLP; and Stephen L. Sepinuck, special UCC advisor at Paul Hastings LLP and adjunct professor at University of Maine School of Law.
Harmon, who introduced herself as “the Chicago panelist,” doubled as the panel’s tour guide. Between cases, she shared facts about the city’s skyline, the Chicago Board of Trade, Lake Michigan, and Frank Lloyd Wright’s home and studio in Oak Park.
The Grant: Present Tense or Nothing
A security interest requires an actual grant, and courts read the granting language closely. Harmon started with Winner Circle Imports, LLC v. Whitney’s Automotive Venture Enterprise, LLC, No. 24-cv-718, 2025 WL 2856525 (E.D. Va. Oct. 8, 2025), which she promptly renamed after The Wieners Circle, her favorite Chicago hot dog spot.
In that case, an asset purchase agreement for three car dealerships said the buyer’s obligations “shall be secured by a perfected lien” in an LLC’s membership interests. The court read that as a plan to document a security interest later, not a present grant, so no security interest was created. Harmon’s advice: “If you’re pulling off a form from a prior deal, go read the grant and make sure it really reads as a present grant.”
Maine’s highest court was more forgiving. County Federal Credit Union v. Madore, 347 A.3d 1014 (Me. 2025) was, in Harmon’s words, “a perfect Chicago case” because it involved a snowmobile. (Her slide showed one on a snowy Chicago street.) The borrower signed the first page of the loan package, a Truth in Lending disclosure stating, “You are giving a security interest in . . . the property described below.” He did not sign at the end of the security agreement section. The Maine Supreme Judicial Court rejected a formalistic approach and held that the signed page, with its present-tense grant, was enough. Harmon’s takeaway: The better answer is still to get every signature block signed.
Describing the Collateral
The security agreement also has to describe the collateral, and two cases came at that issue from opposite directions.
In the first case, In re Payroll Management, Inc., 125 F.4th 1035 (11th Cir. 2025), the debtor had a claim arising from the 2010 Deepwater Horizon explosion. Its security agreement covered contracts but did not specifically describe commercial tort claims, as Article 9 requires. The Eleventh Circuit held that the claim remained a tort claim until the claims process ended with a signed release stating the amount, so the IRS tax lien filed in the meantime had priority.
Sepinuck called the decision “a welcome departure from a line of poorly reasoned cases,” but he questioned the result: “A right to payment can be contingent, and still be a right to payment, and be collateral.”
In the second case, Cannon v. Romeo Systems, Inc., No. 2021-0171, 2025 WL 2848069 (Del. Ch. Oct. 7, 2025), aff’d in part, rev’d in part sub nom. Patterson v. Cannon, 2026 WL 1894081 (Del. June 29, 2026) a pledge agreement described “a warrant to purchase . . . one million shares,” but the warrant was actually for 1 percent of the corporation’s outstanding shares. The Court of Chancery found the description inadequate. The Delaware Supreme Court reversed in relevant part: There was only one warrant, and a description only has to be reasonable.
Who Owns It, and Who Signed It
A fine-art case Weise covered showed that the debtor must own the collateral. In August Uribe Fine Art, LLC v. Dartmilano SRL, No. 22-3104, 2025 WL 3707125 (D.N.J. Dec. 19, 2025), a Picasso painting sold through an auction house went to a storage company; without delivery, the court held, the buyer did not own it, so the security interest claimed in the painting did not attach. Because most personal property has no title registry, Weise noted, checking ownership is where the client’s due diligence comes in.
The person signing also needs authority. In Canon Advance, LLC v. DG Midwest, LLC, No. FST-CV22-6059041, 2025 WL 520981 (Conn. Super. Ct. Feb. 11, 2025), one individual signed a merchant cash advance security agreement on behalf of an LLC. Sepinuck explained that membership alone didn’t give the signer actual authority, and the agreement’s own statement of authority couldn’t create apparent authority, which must come from the principal. “I might claim to be an agent of Microsoft or Meta,” Sepinuck said, “but here’s a shock, I am not.”
After Attachment: Filing and Enforcing
The basics kept going wrong after attachment, too. In PJ Visionary Pte. Ltd. v. Five Senses LLC, 570 P.3d 1 (Haw. Ct. App. 2025), a lender filed only against the parent company, not its two subsidiaries, so their assets were unperfected. “This is such meat and potatoes, basic stuff,” Weise said. “All these problems keep popping up. And yet we talk about it every single year.”
Enforcement brought its own lessons. On repossession, Harmon discussed Lavalley v. Skyline Recovery Service, Inc., 788 F. Supp. 3d 224 (D. Mass. 2025). The debtor objected to the repossession only verbally. The court held that a reasonable jury could still find a breach of the peace. “How many times have we told our kids, ‘Use your words’?” Harmon said. “She used her words.”
Key Takeaways
The year’s cases add up to a short checklist:
- Write the grant in the present tense and get every signature block signed.
- Describe the collateral reasonably, and identify commercial tort claims specifically.
- Confirm the debtor owns what it pledges and confirm the signer’s authority.
- File against every debtor entity, under its correct name.
Many of these were basic mistakes, as the panelists noted. As one of them put it, “These are not hard problems.” Like a Chicago dog, a security agreement only works when every ingredient is there. Skip one, and you could end up as one of next year’s cases.
To learn more about this topic, view the program as on-demand CLE, free for Business Law Section members.

